Today everyone is invited to vote, even though le départage, the “decide between” two towering giants of French song such as Yves Montand and Édith Piafis by no means an easy task!
I really prefer Yves Montan. I just love Édith Piaf’s voice but about this song, I have so many memorable feeling with Yves Montan`s “Sous le ciel de Paris”. I always wish to be under the sky of paris.
Tejal:
I love both the versions!! How can one choose!!??
starman:
Quincy Jones’ version is the best!
Tudor:
je suis sûr et choisis toutes les deux.
Micheal Thompson:
Impossible not to vote for Edith Piaf – but impossible to vote against Yves Montand!
Diane R. Johnson:
toujours Piaf.
Shannon Fabry:
Ahh! I’d have to say Edith on this one, but normally Yves.
Bev:
Montand pour moi
Anna Whitney:
I would have to say Édith Piaf–but only because I grew up listening to her but had never heard Yves Montand. I am American 🙂 I just listened to some of Montand’s music and it is excellent. But I asked a few of my American friends and none of them had heard of Montand either. I wonder why many Americans have heard of Piaf but not Montand?
fereydoon:
J’adore les deux chanteurs mais j’aime la version de Yves Montand.
mohamad:
absolument Yves…il est unique…
Denise LaTart:
Tous les deux, bien sur. La voix d’un homme e la voix d’une femme bien connues.
Comments:
Fatemeh:
I really prefer Yves Montan. I just love Édith Piaf’s voice but about this song, I have so many memorable feeling with Yves Montan`s “Sous le ciel de Paris”. I always wish to be under the sky of paris.
Tejal:
I love both the versions!! How can one choose!!??
starman:
Quincy Jones’ version is the best!
Tudor:
je suis sûr et choisis toutes les deux.
Micheal Thompson:
Impossible not to vote for Edith Piaf – but impossible to vote against Yves Montand!
Diane R. Johnson:
toujours Piaf.
Shannon Fabry:
Ahh! I’d have to say Edith on this one, but normally Yves.
Bev:
Montand pour moi
Anna Whitney:
I would have to say Édith Piaf–but only because I grew up listening to her but had never heard Yves Montand. I am American 🙂 I just listened to some of Montand’s music and it is excellent. But I asked a few of my American friends and none of them had heard of Montand either. I wonder why many Americans have heard of Piaf but not Montand?
fereydoon:
J’adore les deux chanteurs mais j’aime la version de Yves Montand.
mohamad:
absolument Yves…il est unique…
Denise LaTart:
Tous les deux, bien sur. La voix d’un homme e la voix d’une femme bien connues.