His Or Her Cup? – Confusing Possessive Adjectives In French Posted by John Bauer on Apr 11, 2018 in Grammar
Continuing from la semaine dernière (last week), understanding how le genre d’un mot (the gender of a word) affects la grammaire française (French grammar) can be hard to grasp for non-native speakers. Any tips that can help with internalizing why les genres are so important and just how they work makes learning la langue (the language) a little less painful.
A small part of grammar where the concept of les genres exists both en français et en anglais is pronouns. For understanding how les genres work in French, a subset of pronouns, les adjectifs possessifs (possessive adjectives), are especially interesting, since they are gendered words that are attached to the noun in both English and French.
As a reminder, voici les pronoms et les adjectifs possessifs :
Pronoms : Je, tu, il, elle, on, nous, vous, ils
Adjectifs possessifs : Mon/ma/mes, ton/ta/tes, son/sa/ses, notre/nos, votre/vos, leur/leurs
Pronouns: I, you, he, she, one, we, you, they
Possessive Adjectives: My, your, his, her, its, our, their
There is a tricky difference hiding in these small words and knowing about it can help les anglophones (English speakers) avoid making mistakes en français. It has to do with how les adjectifs possessifs treat the grammatical idea of un genre very differently.
In both languages les adjectifs possessifs have to agree with le genre d’un mot:
La tasse → Sa tasse
The cup → His/her/their cup
However, with an example it’s easy to see how in French l’adjectif possessif agrees with the attached noun, but not in English.
En anglais, the possessive adjective agrees with who actually possesses the noun. That makes it impossible to properly translate “son tasse“ without more context.
This difference gets even more complicated when talking about people:
Son patron – His/her/their boss
His boss – Son/sa patron/patronne
La version française (the French version) agrees with the attached noun again, but this time also gives us information about le genre du patron (the gender of the boss). On the other hand, la version anglaise gives us information about who possesses the noun or in this case about le genre de l’employé (the gender of the employee).
Combining all these complicated rules is hard to understand, so let’s break it down further:
La tasse → Sa tasse – The possessive adjective agrees with gender of the word “tasse”.
The cup → His cup – The person who owns the cup is male.
The cup → Her cup – The person who owns the cup is female.
Le patron → Son patron – The boss is male and we do not know the gender of the employee.
The boss → His boss – The employee is male and we do not know the gender of the boss.
La patronne → Sa patronne – The boss is female and we do not know the gender of the employee.
The boss → Her boss – The employee is female and we do not know the gender of the boss.
En français, les adjectifs possessifs always agree with the noun that follows, but in English, the possessive adjective always agrees with who possesses the noun.
If you are still confused, ce qui est important (what’s important) is knowing that you cannot think in English and use les adjectifs possessifs in French like you would en anglais. Don’t worry, with practice la grammaire will become clear.
Build vocabulary, practice pronunciation, and more with Transparent Language Online. Available anytime, anywhere, on any device.