Italian Language Blog
Menu
Search

Fidarsi – Part 2 Posted by on Jun 18, 2010 in Culture

In "Fidarsi – Part 1" I wrote about an article that I had recently read in the Italian magazine ‘Focus’ entitled "Fidarsi è rischioso, non fidarsi è peggio" ("To trust is risky, not to trust is worse"), which is a more optimistic version of the Italian proverb "fidarsi è bene, non fidarsi è meglio" (to trust is good, not to trust is better). One aspect of the article that I found particularly poignant was the discussion about trust between different cultures.

In everyday life when we interact with others people, such as a local storekeeper for example, or someone we happen to sit next to on the bus, we ask ourselves subconsciously, "è affidabile?" (is he/she trustworthy?). "Valutiamo soprattutto lo sguardo, tendendo a diffidare di chi non guarda negli occhi, ma anche l’espressione, l’aspetto, la voce" (We evaluate above all their way of looking at us, having the tendency to distrust those who don’t look us in the eyes, but also their expression, attitude, and voice) says Antonella Marchetti of the Università Cattolica di Milano. Sometimes, during the process of making this judgment, our prejudices and stereotypes interfere: "Non mi fido perché quelli lì sono violenti, ladri, pericolosi" (I don’t trust those because they are violent, thieves, dangerous).

In this instance two factors influence our judgment: il sospetto verso chi è diverso o estraneo al gruppo, e la difficoltà di interpretare velocemente le intenzioni di chi ha una cultura diversa, con una lingua e regole di espressione delle emozioni differenti (the suspicion of whoever is different or outside the group, and the difficulty of rapidly interpreting the intentions of those who come from a different culture, with a different language and different rules for expressing emotions.)

For this reason we need to develop our knowledge of, and empathy with other cultures, languages and customs. Eccoci: in our own small way, you and I are undertaking that process through our discussions in these blogs. Think, for example, of my blog ‘L’Italiano in Cinque Parole’ in which we explored perceptions of Italy and Italian culture.

For me the most interesting outcome of that blog (see https://blogs.transparent.com/italian/litalia-in-cinque-parole/) is the fact that the overwhelming majority of comments concerned the Italian people, their friendliness, helpfulness and empathy. A very encouraging and flattering result, but not what one might expect on face value.

Italy is the land of history, art, architecture, the Rinascimento, pizza, wine, coffee, fashion etc., and tourists seem to spend most of their time taking photos of each other standing in front of leaning towers, renaissance churches, gondolas, and so on. Yet at the end of the day, what comes through as the most important factor is la gente (the people)!

Tags: , ,
Keep learning Italian with us!

Build vocabulary, practice pronunciation, and more with Transparent Language Online. Available anytime, anywhere, on any device.

Try it Free Find it at your Library
Share this:
Pin it

Comments:

  1. andreas:

    Salve Serena,
    Si’ la gente e il pi’u interessante. Ecco per cio’ a me piace guardare l’Antenna5, la cui trasmissione ‘Terra nostra’ mostra non solo le bellezze dell’Italia, ma anche le persone molto differenti.
    Andreas

  2. Bill Rohwer:

    Cara Serena,

    This pair of blogs have been fascinating to me in several ways, but one in particular has captured me: the conviction of i stranieri that Italiani exhibit “friendliness, helpfulness and empathy.” What’s striking to me about this result of your survey is this: it matches exactly the descriptions that many Italian friends have given me of the Americans they’ve met in their visits to the US!

    As i’ve written before, my experience in Italy is that gli Italiani are polite, helpful and welcoming, while at the same time maintaining distance and reserving judgment — often for a year or two. After that period of evaluation, they can become truly warm, truly friendly, and even very affectionate and emotionally attached.

    My experience in the US, where I’ve lived since birth, is that initially there is apparent openness and friendliness but that it’s superficial and never develops into anything more.

    Curious, no?


Leave a comment: